CEO Leadership During COVID-19

In a new report, McKinsey & Company reveals the routines and approaches that top executives have adopted to help cope with the pandemic. “Once the crisis is over, everyone is likely to remember how CEOs acted,” the report says. Clark Beecher, managing partner of Beecher Reagan, weighs in on the impact of the crisis in a new “Talent Talks” podcast.

January 20, 2021 – The coronavirus pandemic has been an epic test of character and determination for millions of people around the world. Nothing compares with the sacrifice of workers on the front lines in hospitals and other essential services. In the business context, CEOs have had to cope with extraordinary demands: for them, the pandemic has been an ultimate leadership test, according to a new report by Homayoun Hatami, Pal Erik Sjatil, and Kevin Sneader of McKinsey & Company.

Over the past few months, the McKinsey partners spoke with business leaders around the globe about how they are coping both personally and professionally. Many told McKinsey about the microhabits—daily routines and ways of working—that they have adopted to help them, and their companies, weather this crisis and emerge stronger from it.

Coping with the sudden shutdown of the global economy was hard enough; figuring out how to restart in such an uncertain environment is, if anything, even harder, many told McKinsey. CEOs are expected to show “deliberate calm” and “bounded optimism.” The McKinsey report notes that everyone wants them to demonstrate empathy—and, at the same time, be highly engaged and fact based in their actions. They are expected to make a positive difference in people’s lives with their leadership and wield both telescope and microscope adroitly. Yet, for all their expertise, they are grappling with many new questions for which they don’t have answers, even as their teams look to them for direction. The COVID-19 crisis is a once-in-a-century event, and no training or experience in previous downturns has prepared CEOs for it.

Some are energized by the challenges and feel closer than ever to their teams. “There is far more personal contact,” said the CEO of a financial-services company. Others are taking a step back to reimagine their company and industry. Even so, exhaustion can quickly set in. CEOs have been “on” pretty much 24/7.

Know Your Strengths

With this crisis, the McKinsey report emphasizes that it is critical to know your strengths and pace yourself. You may need to delegate more, engaging others to help, if you find managing the multiple demands on you too tough. It also means being particularly careful with your time management. Some CEOs have told McKinsey that the travel ban stemming from the COVID-19 crisis has helped them unlock valuable personal time—even as they have ramped up the volume and frequency of meetings via video. “We’re all discovering how much of a capacity trap travel is,” the CEO of a leading global consumer-goods company told McKinsey. “I feel a quite calming sense of control over my own time because I’m just less backlogged, less tired.”

How Our Expectations of CEOs Will Change in a Post-Pandemic World

In this brand new episode of ‘Talent Talks,’ Hunt Scanlon Media host Rob Adams is joined by Clark Beecher, managing partner of Beecher Reagan. Here, Mr. Beecher examines the impact of the pandemic on executive recruiting, leadership, and how the crisis will likely alter our expectations of future CEOs. Listen now!

It is easy to be overwhelmed by videoconferences or email; some CEOs told McKinsey the volume of their email has more than doubled during the crisis, as employees and other stakeholders turn to them personally for answers. To manage their time better, some are capping the length of internal meetings to 20 minutes or 45 minutes rather than an hour. They’re also more inclined to pick up the phone. In the current climate of physical distancing, “a quick call can be more effective and more human” than email, one CEO told McKinsey.

Seizing the Moment

“Once the crisis is over, everyone is likely to remember how CEOs acted during the pandemic,” the McKinsey report said. “To pass this toughest leadership test, CEOs are paying even more attention to what they say and do. CEOs are used to creating a narrative about their leadership agenda when they first move into the job. In the COVID-19 crisis, those are being updated to help employees, customers and stakeholders make sense of their actions.”

Being more directly personal is one way of bolstering a change of narrative. One CEO openly shared his insights with McKinsey from the lockdown, talking about the importance of connections with colleagues to frame the behaviors and ambitions he would like to see in his teams. “Bonding with colleagues can help increase everyone’s individual resilience and grit,” he said.

Many CEOs are talking more often about their own and their companies’ purpose and the values they stand for. “When you are a telecom company and you start producing ventilators for the local hospitals, your company’s purpose takes a new meaning. I have had many more dialogues around what we stand for than I used to,” one CEO told McKinsey.

COVID-19 has also flattened organizations and increased the intensity of communication: CEOs talk more often to colleagues previously addressed by line management. “Normally, when you have challenging news, you really like to have your frontline leaders communicate it because they have a relationship with their colleagues,” the CEO of a healthcare-equipment company told McKinsey. “For the pandemic, I did global town halls, and I’m super candid: I gave the good news and the bad news. I expressed gratitude directly and skipped all the management layers.”

Create Symbolic Acts

In a crisis, a leader’s steps are subject to intense scrutiny and overinterpretation. “During this pandemic, CEOs have had to be extremely thoughtful about the nature and sequence of their actions to illustrate the new style of management and the new priorities,” the McKinsey report said. “It’s striking to note that, in many companies with a clear direction, the leadership team frequently refers to an event that achieves almost legendary status—essentially, a foundational myth—even if it dates back a few years. In usual times, this could have been an off-site retreat at which the management team bonded over a new strategy.”

During the COVID-19 crisis, more symbolic and surprising moments offer themselves up, as companies contribute to society more broadly. The McKinsey report found that some CEOs are giving up their pay; others are donating their bonuses to relevant charities linked to corporate initiatives or to fight COVID-19 directly. They are also spending more time on the front line. Others are making their physical presence felt: The CEO of a sports-equipment maker personally greeted customers in E-Commerce drives on Saturdays to welcome them, listen to their concerns, and roleplay to his teams the new way of serving customers. The CEO of a major private-equity firm said he has been talking to employees about previous crises after discovering that about half of them weren’t working during the 2008 global financial crisis and 70 percent hadn’t experienced the 2000 dot-com crisis. “For the young people in our organization, this is the time you will learn more and create more opportunity for your career than any other time,” the individual said. “We have to essentially tell the stories, build the lore, and keep the connection because there’s a fair amount of anxiety.”

Mobilize the Troops

If there were ever any doubt about it, all CEOs who were interviewed told McKinsey that their teams make the difference more than ever. “During this pandemic, the cohesion of your team is absolutely critical,” one said, echoing many others. CEOs said they have learned to appreciate their teams in new ways—often meeting their kids and visiting their homes over video. One leader makes a point of starting every single meeting with a note of appreciation for his team’s achievements. The crisis is also revealing the team members more prone to panic under pressure—and those taking the intensity in stride.

What Companies are Looking for in a CEO During a Pandemic
CEO selection shifted markedly in the months after the World Health Organization declared a pandemic, according to a new study by Heidrick & Struggles. Companies have been putting more importance on previous CEO experience and they are also looking externally more often for their next leader. Let’s go inside this latest leadership report.

Many CEOs now talk to their team multiple times a week instead of once every two weeks. The global management team at a major manufacturing company used to meet four times a year; now, it convenes three times a week. The conversations are also different, “much more focused on real business decisions at hand, and we skip the generalities,” one CEO told McKinsey. Another describes how the crisis has lifted her own and her team’s “metabolic rates.” Postcrisis, she wants to retain that faster pace of interaction.

Additionally, many CEOs have noticed how smaller, decentralized teams with a clear mandate and direction have been able to make decisions more effectively than in the pre-COVID-19 governance. The greater efficiency also has come about because interpersonal politics have diminished at the top, said one leader. “We have learned to trust each other much more,” said the CEO of a global consumer-goods company. “We are doing things at an incredible pace as a company as people rapidly flip into problem-solving mode. Standing up whole new factories in days. We’re revising our strategy in two weeks. And I think it’ll be more right than wrong.”

Staying Ahead

In a crisis, it can be easy for CEOs to busy themselves with urgent meetings and operational issues. “But the tendency to make yourself busy can also mask an underlying vulnerability, it’s a way of showing you are in control, just when you fear you may not be,” the McKinsey report said. “To be truly effective, you need to be a leader who can look beyond the daily conflagrations, thinking and planning for the longer term even as you put out the fires raging around you.”

Related: Major Paradigm Shifts Coming Out of the Coronavirus Crisis

Every day in this crisis can seem like an eternity, yet McKinsey says that the decisions you take now will shape your legacy as a company leader. What should that longer-term view be? The vision you sketch out could focus on specific and tangible goals: classic metrics such as profitability, growth, market share and so on. “But you will also need to have in mind an endgame of sorts, a broader vision that incorporates goals such as the ultimate purpose of the company, the values it stands for, and the sorts of people it will and won’t attract as employees and as customers,” the report said.

Some companies are focusing on themes such as sustainability and climate risk that were already significant before the crisis—and which some CEOs expect to loom even larger once the pandemic has abated. “This is an opportunity today where you need to build the world in a better way,” the CEO of a leading industrial-manufacturing and -technology company told McKinsey. “This is one of the biggest responsibilities we have as leaders.”

8 Key Traits to Look for When Hiring a Turnaround CEO
A new report from ON Partners reveals the top characteristics to look for in a candidate for the job of leading your company out of crisis. Pay attention to past performance, attention to finances, an operational mindset, and a knack for digesting data and distilling the underlying issues, for starters.

To help think through longer-term priorities, CEOs are trying to set aside explicit time to ponder what’s next. The head of a U.S. grocery chain told McKinsey he takes a half day with his team every week to think collectively about the future, seeking to frame the questions rather than the answers. “I find that incredibly liberating,” the leader said. “You get away from the day to day.” Many CEOs agree that this is the time to accelerate change. “We are in a grace period where my organization expects change and is ready to accept it,” said one senior executive. Another CEO said: “This is the moment to shape our market.”

While having an endgame in mind is key, staying focused on it can be challenging. “There are so many problems that need resolving right now that CEOs can quickly be pulled in multiple directions,” said the McKinsey report. “Some are opting for radical simplification—focusing only on a handful of priorities and leaving the rest to their teams—and have been surprised by just how effective that is showing to be.”

The COVID-19 crisis is proving to be a revealing test of leadership. “Emerging from it strengthened, compassionate, confident, forward looking, and successful will be those leaders who can cope with the extraordinary personal and professional challenges,” said the McKinsey report. “They will be the ones who know themselves the best and can respond to the many challenges. Unlike in Greek mythology, there is no external deity who will fly to the rescue. But embracing and adopting a set of thoughtful, tested, and far-sighted microhabits can be a recipe for both business success and personal well-being. Not all of these ways of working will endure once the crisis has abated, but new habits that prove effective in the heat of the crisis can stick—and help CEOs become better leaders.”

Related: Leading Through Uncertainty and Fear

Contributed by Scott A. Scanlon, Editor-in-Chief; Dale M. Zupsansky, Managing Editor; and Stephen Sawicki, Managing Editor – Hunt Scanlon Media

Share This Article


Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments