March 15, 2022 – Over the past year, Christian Schmidt and his colleagues have had dozens of discussions with CFOs to understand how they have been navigating the pandemic era and are adapting as leaders to this challenging and often unpredictable environment. What became apparent during these conversations is that the pandemic created or accelerated some key trends that will become an essential part of any CFO’s repertoire in the long term. All of this is examined in a new report from Egon Zehnder. The role of CFO has always been exceptionally challenging. “Those at the top of their game are masterful strategists yet able to dive deeply into – and solve – often highly complex and intricate finance issues that are essential to a company’s fate,” said Mr. Schmidt. “The past months have further challenged CFOs, and many have been critical in ensuring their companies’ survival. However, as the dust settles and many organizations are coping – even thriving – in the new normal, it is worthwhile to outline some of the key trends that are already impacting the role requirements for CFOs,” he noted.
In its report, Egon Zehnder says it wanted to reflect on these developments, highlighting those that are likely to remain with us, which will require unique skills and capabilities from CFOs in the future.
The study offered four major trends to pay attention to in the months, and years, ahead:
1. The CFO as Co-pilot
More than ever, the pandemic has demanded “all hands-on deck” by senior executives to ensure business continuity, or even survival. “In addition to the CEO, the CFO has played a pivotal role in this effort, often ensuring that the company remains in business,” said Mr. Schmidt. “The CFO must stay on top of the function 24/7, which entails extremely close collaboration with the CEO. Moreover, we have also observed that remote working, as well as fear and worries among employees, has required CFOs to increasingly focus on the ‘human’ aspect of their role, which is not only to lead the finance function, but also to motivate, energize, nurture, retain, and care for people across their organizations. This is naturally expected from the CEO but carries additional weight when the CFO steps up to a more prominent leadership role.”
“Before the crisis, companies were increasingly looking for CFOs who could act as true business partners to the CEO to help lead organizations in an increasingly complex, uncertain, and volatile world,” said Mr. Schmidt. “The days of the hero CEO and number cruncher CFO are truly over. As a natural and often obvious CEO successor, companies should consider bringing on CFOs who excel as leaders of people and who can connect and engage with others at a deeply human and motivational level. In our work with clients, a CFO’s leadership capabilities and their ability to effectively connect across organizations have become must-have requirements and arguably the most important lens through which we assess CFOs.”
2. The CFO as a Flexible Planner
When the pandemic hit with full force in 2020, companies were forced to abandon carefully planned budgets. In many industries both budgets and scenario planning proved to be futile and even counter-productive exercises, according to the Egon Zehnder report. “One of the most disconcerting aspects of the crisis for CFOs – who, by definition, must be focused on precise details – has been the inability to make forecasts and predictions with any level of certainty, given the totally unprecedented nature of the economic disruption,” the study said. “After trying to ramp up the pace of scenario planning in the early days of the crisis, many CFOs decided to stop and focus on detecting trends and patterns, seeking new learnings in the process.”
Christian Schmidt, based in London, focuses on the industrial sector, assisting clients in natural resources, process, and manufacturing industries, with a particular focus on mining and metals. In addition to executive and board searches, he has deep experience managing cross-border leadership assessment and development projects for global clients. As a member of the firm’s financial officers practice, Mr. Schmidt has also led numerous CFO searches for both public and private companies, and leads Egon Zehnder’s CFO practice in the U.K.
“Now that the worst of the crisis appears to have subsided, budgets and scenario planning are making a comeback,” said Mr. Schmidt. “However, what will remain is a need for much greater flexibility in thinking and acting by CFOs, and for them to be deeply curious in the world around in order to remain agile, pragmatic and open to events and scenarios that were previously unthinkable. The pandemic has forced executives to expand their horizons and think beyond static budgets and predictions of what may be possible – as both best- and worst-case scenarios remain viable and realistic options.”
3. Getting More Adept at Digitization
Digitization of finance and other functions has been a hot topic for some time, and the COVID-19 crisis accelerated this trend. This is partly because companies have continued to trim down every function, prompting the need to increasingly rely on digitization and automation, according to Egon Zehnder. “The rapid progress in cloud computing has further sped up this trend as has remote working and the increasing globality of organizations,” said the study. “Many organizations need to have deep insight in real time into the performance of any unit across the world, increasing the need for digitization. What this means for the CFO is that she or he will increasingly be able to rely on algorithms when it comes to important decision making. Rather than having to look over the shoulder of the head of FP&A, the CFO will receive actionable insights at the push of the button.”
Nonetheless, the CFO will need to remain “on top of the numbers” and not lose essential accounting and controlling skills. However, the increasing digitization will allow the CFO to focus more on his or her role as a co-pilot of the business and as a leader of people. As such, digitization will require CFOs to deliver even deeper insights than before.
4. Champion of ESG and Sustainability
Egon Zehnder notes that environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues have been a focus for companies long before the pandemic. The current crisis, however, has highlighted the importance of ESG and sustainability to businesses, and stakeholder scrutiny has increased significantly over the past months. The more sustainable a business is, the more resilient it will be to withstand shocks, such as a global pandemic. Also, investors are playing an increasingly important part in calling on companies to strengthen their ESG performance, and already now cheaper capital is available in some industries to those companies that are recognized as strong leaders in sustainability.
“A concerted effort by business and society to stop climate change may have previously seemed impossible,” said Mr. Schmidt. “But now the shared experience of a pandemic – and the phenomenal response of vaccine development – have demonstrated that not only is a global catastrophe possible, but so is the possibility to overcome this environmental challenge both locally and globally.”
Hunt Scanlon Media has just released our latest special issue of ESR. This time around we take an in-depth look at the challenges financial services firms are facing in their hunt for new talent.
We cover it all: How CFOs are confronting new layers of risk in the pandemic era; the rapid and dramatic change coming at the CFO; using people analytics to acquire top talent, predict performance & reduce turnover; and why banks are turning to search firms. We even provide our latest “Financial Fifty Recruiters” ranking of financial services search firms! In this special issue of ESR, Hunt Scanlon editors take an extraordinary inside look at recruiting during these unprecedented times. Click here and enjoy.
With regards to the “social” aspect of ESG, the Black Lives Matter movement, which gained momentum after the murder of George Floyd in May 2020, only accelerated societal expectations with regards to companies’ diversity initiatives and put them under further scrutiny by internal and external stakeholders to drive a transparent and proactive DEI agenda.
“Companies’ social performance and engagement with communities has been receiving increased attention year-on-year, and with further sophistication by NGOs, societal groups, and exposure to social media, this trend is bound to continue,” said Mr. Schmidt. “Sound governance, or the ‘G’ in ESG, will be critical for companies to make meaningful progress on their sustainability agenda. This not only implies having the right corporate structures in place, but also devising the right measures, monitoring process, and devising the right interventions.”
“Yet CFOs have traditionally had an ambivalent relationship with sustainability,” said Mr. Schmidt. “As the guardians of the company’s purse strings, they often see sustainability as an expensive luxury at worst or a necessary risk-mitigation exercise at best. While this is changing rapidly, we believe that there is a clear need for CFOs to play a more active and impactful role with regards to how sustainability is managed.”
The Egon Zehnder report lays out these duties of today’s CFO: First, as a key partner to the CEO, the CFO is uniquely placed to constructively challenge and debate these issues with the board, CEO, and executive committee, enhancing the quality of thinking and output in the process. This requires that the CFO views his or her responsibilities as a broader leadership role that goes beyond the management of the finance function.
Second, the CFO must be the driving force behind helping their company develop accepted standards of accounting and disclosure for ESG performance. “During our conversations with CFOs, many expressed their desire to have more globally established accounting standards for ESG,” said the report. “Over the past several years, we have seen an increase in the number of organizations that are trying to provide some guidance to CFOs and investors, including SASB, B Corp, GRI, and International Integrated Reporting Council (IIRC).”
Third, the CFO is in an ideal and the most credible position of all executives to make a business case on why world-class ESG performance is good for business. Their word in this matter carries weight.
“In many capital-intensive industries, world-class safety performance is widely accepted as indispensable to enhance productivity and profitability,” said Mr. Schmidt. “However, we have yet to see a similar belief in the profit-enhancing powers of being a leader on all matters related to ESG across the entire spectrum of industries. As such, CFOs need to complement their focus on risk management with the ability to see direct connections between ESG performance and the company’s bottom line and communicate this business case in a compelling and convincing manner internally and externally.”
Separating Good from Great
Like other functions, the role of CFO is evolving rapidly in line with the changing needs of businesses, the evolving external landscape, and shifting stakeholder and shareholder expectations, said Mr. Schmidt. “The current pandemic has brought to the fore and accelerated some key trends which will have a profound impact on the nature and requirements of the CFO role,” he said. “Functional mastery will remain essential, but it will be strong leadership on the issues highlighted above that will separate good from great CFOs in the future. As we support companies in developing their CFOs – and cultivating their successors – we often work with them to build flexibility and a learning mindset among their finance leaders to adapt to changing circumstances and requirements.”
Mr. Schmidt said that “in doing so, we have found the following traits to be critical for successful performance: the ability to connect with others and communicate a persuasive vision, the strength to bounce back from reversals and see opportunities in challenges, generating new insights creatively and analytically, and a deep curiosity in the world around them, without preconceived notions, for the benefit of their continued learning and development.”
Contributed by Scott A. Scanlon, Editor-in-Chief; Dale M. Zupsansky, Managing Editor; and Stephen Sawicki, Managing Editor – Hunt Scanlon Media