How CEOs Can Overcome Setbacks and Emerge Stronger

August 12, 2026 – Executive search firms are increasingly being called upon to assess more than a candidate’s track record of growth, transformation, and financial performance. As boards search for CEOs capable of leading through persistent uncertainty, resilience has become a critical component of the leadership profile. Search consultants are placing greater emphasis on how executives have responded to setbacks, navigated failed strategies, adapted to changing circumstances, and maintained the confidence of boards, employees, and investors under pressure. In today’s CEO searches, the ability to recover, recalibrate, and make sound decisions amid ambiguity can be just as important as a history of success.

For CEOs, encountering setbacks is a common occurrence, but how these challenges are handled is key to moving forward with composure, according to a recent report by Odgers. The study pointed to Reed Hastings, the co-founder of Netflix, who made a decision in 2011 that nearly derailed the company. He announced that Netflix would split its streaming and DVD rental services into two separate entities, a move that would require customers to manage two separate accounts with separate billing. It resulted in an overwhelmingly negative response from customers and the market. The company’s stock price plummeted, losing nearly 77 percent of its value, and the backlash caused Hastings to reverse the decision, abandoning the plan entirely.

“This powerful leadership lesson is that Hastings distinguished between a flawed strategy and flawed execution,” the Odgers report said. “Rather than abandoning the long-term strategic direction, he adjusted the timing, execution and customer transition plan. For CEOs, that ability to separate vision from implementation is often the difference between resilience and overreaction.”

“In a world where leaders are increasingly required to make decisions without complete information, resilience is often less about avoiding mistakes and more about responding constructively when assumptions prove wrong,” the report explained. “Mistakes and failures happen, especially at the CEO level where the stakes are highest. But today’s CEOs are operating in a markedly different environment. Geopolitical instability, supply chain disruption, workforce shortages, technological transformation and the rapid emergence of AI have increased both the pace and complexity of decision making – and uncertainty is constant.”

“The challenge is no longer simply how leaders recover from a setback,” the Odgers report noted. “It is how they continue to make sound decisions when disruption, ambiguity and incomplete information is the norm.”

Odgers explores how CEOs can build resilience, exercise judgement and create the conditions for sustained performance through uncertainty.

Classify the Setback

When faced with a setback, the first step for any CEO is to classify its severity, according to the Odgers report. “Is it truly career-ending, or merely frustrating? It is easy to catastrophize and magnify the impact of the setback,” it said. “Understanding the true severity of the setback is also vital for planning an appropriate response. It is easier to determine the true impact and best course of action with some emotional distance and a clear mind. Leaders rarely have the luxury of complete information. The challenge is often not determining the perfect answer, but exercising sound judgement when there is uncertainty. Many of the most consequential decisions CEOs face today involve competing priorities, evolving risks and incomplete data. Resilient leaders develop confidence in their decision-making processes rather than waiting for perfect clarity.”

Top Five Decision-Making Traps

One of the greatest tests of resilient leadership is not how CEOs respond after a setback, but how they make decisions while navigating one, the Odgers report explained. Under pressure, even highly experienced leaders can fall into predictable decision-making traps that compound existing challenges.

Odgers provides these are the main decision-making pitfalls to avoid:

1. Escalating commitment: Continuing to invest in an underperforming initiative simply because significant resources have already been committed.

2. Short-term overreaction: Abandoning a sound long-term strategy in response to temporary setbacks or market pressure.

3. Analysis paralysis: Delaying action while searching for certainty in situations where uncertainty is unavoidable.

4. Confirmation bias: Prioritizing information that supports existing views while discounting contradictory evidence.

5. Leadership isolation: Making critical decisions without sufficiently challenging assumptions through trusted advisers, peers or board members.

The Hidden Challenges Every First-Time CEO Faces

The corner office has never been more accessible—or more demanding. As boards increasingly turn to a new generation of leaders to navigate disruption, growth, and transformation, first-time CEOs are stepping into roles that require a fundamentally different set of skills than those that propelled them to the top. While many arrive with impressive track records, the transition often presents challenges that are difficult to anticipate until they are sitting in the chief executive’s chair.

“Knowing when to stay the course is important, but so is recognizing when circumstances have changed and a different approach is required,” the Odgers report said.

Communicate Transparently

During periods of uncertainty, CEOs must communicate not only with employees but also with boards, investors, customers and other stakeholders, according to the Odgers report. “Resilience is demonstrated through clarity, consistency and transparency, particularly when confidence is under pressure,” the study said. “This means planning a communication strategy that addresses both the practical and emotional aspects of the situation. Effective communication balances transparency with reassurance, providing stakeholders with confidence that the organization has a clear path forward.”

Related: How Boards and CEOs Can Close the First-Year Learning Gap

“CEOs should also consider who else needs reassurance during this time,” the report continued. “Setbacks often impact others in ways leaders do not initially realize. Acknowledging and addressing these effects is important to maintain leadership team morale, trust, engagement and cohesion.”

Leverage Trusted Advisors 

“One of the greatest risks during a setback is decision-making in an echo chamber,” Odgers noted. “High-performing CEOs actively seek challenge from people who can identify blind spots, test assumptions and provide objective perspectives.”

Plan the Next Steps

“Overcoming a setback requires CEOs to establish achievable short- and long-term goals that restore momentum and main strategic focus,” Odgers also explained. “The most successful leaders balance decisive action with the flexibility to adapt as circumstances evolve.”

Build Resilient Teams

Resilience is often discussed as a personal trait, but increasingly it is an organizational capability, according to the Odgers report. “The most effective CEOs recognize that long-term success depends not only on how they respond to uncertainty, but how their organizations respond,” the firm said. “Building resilience means creating cultures where people become comfortable with change, challenge assumptions and continue to execute effectively through disruption. When resilience is embedded across the organization, performance becomes less dependent on any one leader and more capable of withstanding future shocks.”

Reflect and Assess

A necessary step for CEOs is reviewing the actions that contributed to the setback. “When reflecting, leaders should resist the urge to blame external factors and instead seek to understand what could have been done differently,” the Odgers report said. “They should also reconnect with trusted members of their network, seek honest feedback and look for opportunities to improve.”

Maintain a Growth Mindset

At the heart of resilient leadership is a growth mindset, the Odgers report explained. “Traditionally, resilience has been viewed as the ability to recover from setbacks,” the firm noted. “Increasingly, resilience is about adaptability. It is the capacity to absorb new information, adjust course when required and continue moving forward despite ambiguity.”

In fast-changing environments, Odgers pointed out that adaptability can become a greater competitive advantage than certainty. The most successful CEOs go beyond recovery. The study said to use setbacks as opportunities to learn, recalibrate and strengthen both their judgement and their organizations. They remain open to new information, honest about what has changed and willing to adjust course when circumstances demand it.

“The most effective CEOs do not avoid setbacks; they build organizations capable of learning from them,” the Odgers report concluded. “Resilience is therefore not simply a personal attribute. It is a strategic capability that enables leaders to make better decisions under pressure, adapt when assumptions prove wrong and maintain performance through uncertainty. The question is no longer whether setbacks will occur, but whether leaders and organizations have the resilience to respond effectively when they do.”

Related: CEO Turnover Surges as Boards Bet on First-Time Leaders

Contributed by Scott A. Scanlon, Editor-in-Chief and Dale M. Zupsansky, Executive Editor  – Hunt Scanlon Media